Here's something else for you
2000-2002 SL1 or SL2 Saturn
I got a 2001 SL1 last year for $5500 with 52,000 miles and it's proved to be a great car.
My story is I got a new job 45 miles away from my doorstep, that's a total of 90 miles, I own a Toyota Tacoma it's paid for, I love it can't beat a Toyota, but it got at best 15 mpg's, I was spending $300 a month just on gas, so I figured out I had to get a car for around $5000 with a $150 and got at least 30 mpg's to come out even, but I now have paid off the loan on the Saturn, now money ahead! The Saturn is a great little car I get at best 38 mpg's at a low in the cold winters of Wisconsin 32 mpg's, I've put on about 30,000 miles and had to spend $96.50 parts and labor for a front wheel bearing, besides oil changes. It's not the smoothest, quietest ride in the world, It may not have a H (Honda civic) on the grill but if it did I would have paid almost 3 times as much for it.
Well just trying to help you out, good luck that $5000 price range is a hard one